All Issues
Year: 2006  Vol. 10   Num. 1  - Jan/Mar Print:
Original Article
Versão em PDF PDF in Portuguese Texto Text in Portuguese
Comparative Analysis of Vestibular Answers to Caloric Trial in Patients Submitted to Vestibular Examination With and Without Using Anti-dizziness Medication
Anlise Comparativa das Respostas Vestibulares Prova Calrica em Pacientes Submetidos ao Exame Vestibular Sem e Com o Uso de Medicao Anti-vertiginosa
Rita Mor1, Daniela de Moraes Jardim Garcia2, Polyana da Silveira Bergamo Friedmann2
Key words:
Vestibule. Caloric tests. Eletronystagmography. Vestibular diseases. Ddrug interactions. Drug effects. Vertigo. Dizziness.

Purpose: This study compared the results of the caloric trial in examination of patients undergoing the vestibular evaluation with and without using anti-dizziness medication. Methods: 29 individuals were evaluated, users of anti-dizzy medication under medical direction for, at least, 30 days. The individuals were submitted to prior vestibular evaluation without using any medication, having as a result Irritative (IPVS) or Deficient Peripheric Vestibular Syndrome (DPVS). While using the medication they were submitted to a new evaluation. Results: Analyzing the group it was noticed that 50% of the individuals with DPVS had their examinations brought back to normal in the second evaluation. Another finding was the increase of the post-caloric response, in the second evaluation. Conclusions: A change to the caloric trial was verified, altering the diagnosis, and increasing post-caloric responses in the examinations carried out using anti-dizziness medication.


Vestibular system, together with visual and proprioceptive systems, is responsible for body balance. Sensorial information from these systems, integrated by Central Nervous System, determines the maintenance of body balance. Central Nervous System performs the integration from visual sensorial, vestibular and proprioceptive information in specific centers placed on brainstem and cerebellum, and also determines head, neck, vertebral column, legs, arms, eyes movements and all body muscles, which are needed to guide and keep it in balance1.

Vestibular system disorders can present symptoms such as vertigo and other types of dizziness or unbalance, mainly on adults and elderly people, affecting specially females 2,3,4.

Body unbalance and other types of dizziness come from the non-integration from vestibular, visual and proprioceptive information received by central nervous system. Balance disorders (non-rotatory dizziness and vertigo- rotatory dizziness) are common symptoms on peripheral or central vestibulopathy. Vertigo is normally followed by neurovegetative symptoms such as nausea, vomit, intense sudoresis and paleness2. Feelings of undulatory movement, oscillation, body swinging and fluctuation are reported as dizziness3. Tinnitus, hypoacusis, feeling of pressure on the head, hypersensitiveness to sounds, weakness, falls, headaches, sight darkening, difficulty of eye fixation, sleep disorders, difficulty when concentrating, memory confusion, visual hallucination, anxiety, depression and phobias are also reported as dizziness2,3, by patients.

Otoneurological evaluation, which covers audiological and vestibular evaluations, allows the functioning characterization of hearing and vestibular systems and their relations with Central Nervous System. It also aims to promote the localization of peripheral lesions (labyrinth and pair VIII) and/or central lesions (nucleus, passages and interrelation with central nervous system) 2,3,5. Currently, computed vectoeletronystagmography is the main evaluation method for vestibular system evaluation. It precisely measures the parameters of oculomotor-vestibular function an presents larger sensitiveness when identifying signs of vestibular implications6,7.

Antivertigo medication is one of the ways used for vestibular disfunction treatment. This type of medication can change the results of vestibular and oculomotor tests which compose otoneurological evaluation when accomplishment without dismissing them, as vestibular system is sensitive to several medication effects2,8. Some studies suggest that different substances can change eye movement2,9. Sedatives, antiemetics, anti-histaminics are used to ease vertigo symptoms and then suppress vestibular ocular reflex (VOR), observing suppression of nystagmus speed inducing in caloric terms during vestibular evalutation9,10,11. Therefore, vestibular exam should be done without using non-essential medication such as antivertigo, tranquilizers, anticonvulsion, narcotic, anti-histaminics, antiemetics and antiallergics, because they can excite or inhibit vestibular function8,12.

The target of this study was to compare the results from caloric tests from patients submitted to vestibular evaluation with and without antivertigo medication use.


29 subjects were examined, 20 women and 0 men, aging between 20 and 77 years, with average age of 54.24 years. They were selected from a list of patients assisted at Otoneurology ambulatory - CEFAC. They had already done vestibular exam without antivertigo medication and returned to new evaluation with such medication use. They were informed on the purpose of this research, and agreed to sign a free and clear consent document for inclusion. The exams were done at Otoneurology ambulatory - CEFAC through computed vectoeletronystagmography, done with a digital Neurograff, with specific software (Vec-win). To do caloric test, it was used NGR05 Neurograff air, considering the standard rules previously established 12,13.

Otoneurological evaluation consisted of vestibular exam with the following tests: research of posicional nystagmus, calibration of eye movement, research of spontaneous nytagmus with open and closed eyes, research of semi-spontaneous nystagmus, research of saccadic movements, research of pendular tracking at a speed of 0.10Hz, 0.20Hz and 0.40HZ, research of optokinetic nystagmus and research of post-caloric nystagmus through caloric test with air at 42C e 18C. In this study we decided to compare only the responses from the research of post-caloric test due to the fact that it is a specific evaluation of vestibular function and it allows to evaluate each of the labyrinth separately4,5,9. In this study we decided to compare only the responses from the research of post-caloric test due to the fact that it is a specific evaluation of vestibular function and it allows to evaluate each of the labyrinth separately4,5,9. For this study, it was chosen the individuals whose first exam presented Irritative Peripheral Vestibular Syndrome (IPVS) or Deficient Peripheral Vestibular Syndrome (DPVS) as a result and were also taking antivertigo medication, at least for 30 days, under medical orientation. The exams taken as (IPVS) presented DP (directional preponderance) > 22% or hyperreflexia (angular speed of the slow component >19/s) and the ones taken as DPVS presented LP (labyrinthine predominance) > 33% or hyporreflexia. (Angular speed of the slow component >2/s) 12,13. All individuals did the first vestibular exam under previous diet and without antivertigo medication use. The medication used by patients on the second exam was: cinarizine dichloridrate, flunarizine dichloridrate, Betahistine dichloridrate and Ginkgo-biloba Egb-761 extract.

The statistic methods used were: Student-t test for paired data, Qui-square test and Mann Whitney test. Student-t test was controlled by Levene test for equality of variances, with the purpose of verifying the differences between age averages of the genre group. The level of significance was 5% (0.050) to statistical test application.

This study was evaluated and approved by Comit de tica em Pesquisa (Ethics Committee) of the Specialization Center on Clinical Phonoaudiology, n 167/03. And it was considered riskless and with the need of free and clear consent (Annex 1).


It was done a comparative statistical analysis of the group whose individuals were under evaluation A (no medication use) and evaluation B (medication use), using Mann Whitney test, relating sex and age, IPVS and SVPD exam results and sex and changes of post-caloric responses (angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus) between sexes. This analysis had the purpose of verifying possible differences between the age averages and differences between exam results from both groups, male and female. It was found that there are no statistical differences and, so, data were analyzed together.

The group who took part of this study was formed by 17 individual with IPVS and 12 with DPVS, considering alterations presented on caloric tests.

Qui-Square test was applied in order to analyze possible differences of exam results between situations A and B. From this Table we can observe that from the 17 (58.6%) individuals with IPVS in situation A, 12 (41.4%) kept the same result, 5 (17.2%) presented normal exam and none presented deficient exam in situation B. Therefore, from the 12 (41.4%) individuals with DPVS in situation A, 3 of them (10.3%) had unaltered results, 3 (10.3%) presented result of irritative exam and 6 (20.7%) had their exams in normal condition in situation B, that means, 50% of the individuals with DPVS presented expressive improvement in evaluation with antivertigo medication.

From this Table, we can observe that 44.4% of the patients who used Cinarizine/Flunarizine dichloridrate presented an increase of vestibular response. Only 01 case (11.2%) when patient presented IPVS, it was observed a reduction on angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus, making vestibular exam normal.

From this Table it is possible to observe that on cases which Ginkgo Biloba were managed, 51.1% still presented IPVS even after medication use. From cases with DPVS, 7.2% of patients had normal exam and 14.3% presented an increase on angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus on second evaluation.

From this Table, we can observe that from the 06 cases with medication use, 02 of them (33.2%) kept result of IPVS and 02 (33.2%) had an increase of responses making patients with DPVS have normal or irritative diagnosis.

Student-t test was used to paired data on the comparative analysis of values of angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus and it was found that statistically expressive changes between situation A and B, from which it was observed an increase of post-caloric responses on stimulation with cool air on right ear (A and B) and hot air on left ear (A and B). On these situations we have nystagmus beating to left.

N Values presented in this Table do not correspond to the 29 selected individuals, though, in some cases, it was not possible to do the four caloric stimulations (42C RE and LE and 18C RE and LE) due to neurovegetative manifestations presented by patients. In these cases, the exam was interrupted without any loss on its conclusion, as it already characterized an Irritative Peripheral Vestibular Syndrome (IPVS).


The comparative analysis by sex of the studied group in situations A and B was not statistically expressive, though it is important to point out the existence of a sex-related heterogeneous group, in which women predominate. Previous studies reported that vertigo and its associated symptoms are very common among women. This might be due to larger labyrinth susceptibility to functional alterations to distance, and it can be influenced by other clinical disorders from different places and origin, causing hearing and/or vestibular symptoms such as hormone and/or metabolism associated variations with migraine, in which it is observed a greater occurrence in women, and other diseases which make vestibular function5,14,15,16,17,18 sensitive.

The expressive improvement from deficient exams (Table 1) done with medication use as well as the increase on responses of post-caloric nystagmus observed on comparative analysis between situations A and B (Table 2) show that meticulous action can interfere on responses due to its therapeutic action. This action is recommended as a provider of an increase on vestibular function, making vestibluar19 compensation easier. There are reports attesting that some medication acts in a way of stabilizing specific neurotransmitters or increasing cerebral flow and neuronal metabolism7,9,14,19. Among all drugs reported for treatment of patient with vertigo, the most used ones from which good results are achieved are: flunarizine, cinarizine, betahistine, clonazepam, ginkgo biloba and pentoxifiline from which only the last one and clonazepam is not part of this study14,19,20,21,22,23.

Cinarizine and flunarizine have a powerful vestibular suppressor effect, reducing labyrinth excitability due to its peripheral and central antivasoconstrictor action20,21,22,23,24,25. In the analyzed cases (Table 3) we observed an increase of responses in 50% from patients with DPVS submitted to this medication use and only 1 case of reduction on angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus.

In relation to Ginkgo Biloba EGb 761 extract, the studies report its vasoactive, antioxidant and anti-ischemic properties, which favor blood flow on labyrinth microcirculation and on central nervous system (CNS) 20,21,22,23,24,25. In the cases which Ginkgo Biloba were managed (Table 4), 57.1% still presented IPVS even after medication use.

Betahistine is normally used on treatment of peripheral vestibular disorders. It has an inhibitor and facilitator effect on lateral and medium vestibular nuclei. It also provides an increase of vestibular-cochlea bloody flow20,21,22,23,24,25,26,27,28,29. A reduction of nystagmus duration on Decreasing Pendular Rotation Test occurs when medication is used, what differs from the situation analyzed in this study, where caloric test analysis had the preference30. From the 6 cases which used medication (Table 5), only 1 of them presented a reduction on angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus, making patients with IPVS have normal diagnosis in the second situation.

Knowing the medication use effects, it is important to consider the need of a vestibular evaluation without it, as medication can interfere on the results, altering its authenticity. Vestibular evaluation should be done, if possible, without any action from substances that are sensitive to labyrinth.


1. From the result analysis, we can conclude that caloric test on vestibular evaluations with DPVS done without medication use, suffered a diagnosis change to normal condition in 50% of the examined cases with medication use.

2. We also observed an increase of responses of angular speed of the slow component of the nystagmus on exams done with medication use when compared to the exam done without medication from the same subject.


1. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG, Ganana FF, Ganana CF. A hodologia clnica do sistema Vestibular. In: Caovilla HH, Ganaa MM, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG. Equilibriometria Clnica. Vol 1. So Paulo. Ed. Atheneu; 2000. p.5-21.

2. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH. Labirintopatias. Acta Awho, 1991, 10(1):4-16.

3. Menon AD, Sakano E, Weckx, LLM. Consenso sobre vertigem. Revista Brasileira de Orl, So Paulo, 2000, 66(6)supl.11, nov/dez, 2000.

4. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH.Equilibriometria. In: Ganana MM, Vieira RM, Caovilla HH. Princpios de Otoneurologia. Ed. Atheneu, vol.1, So Paulo, 1998, p.23-55. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH.Equilibriometria. In: Ganana MM, Vieira RM, Caovilla HH. Princpios de Otoneurologia. Ed. Atheneu, vol.1, So Paulo, 1998, p.23-55.

5. Mor R, Fragoso M, Taguchi CK, Figueiredo JFFR. Vestibulometria e Fonoaudiologia - Como realizar e interpretar. Ed. Lovise, So Paulo, 2001.

6. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG, Frazza, MM. A contribuio da equilibriometria. In: Ganana MM. Vertigem tem cura? Ed. Lemos, So Paulo1998, p. 93-116.

7. Caovilla HH, Ganana MM, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG, Ganana FF, Ganana CF. O registro dos movimentos oculares. In: Caovilla HH, Ganana MM, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG. Equilibriometria Clnica. Vol. 1. So Paulo. Ed. Atheneu; 2000. p.31-40.

8. Munhoz ML, Munhoz MSL, Caovilla HH, Ganana, MM. Agentes antiinflamatrios no-hormonais e a funo labirntica. Arq Bras Med, 67(2);149-151, 1993.

9. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG, Frazza, MM. As etapas da equilibriometria. In; Caovilla HH, Ganana MM, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG. Equilibriometria Clnica. Vol. 1. So Paulo. Ed. Atheneu; 2000. p 41-79.

10. Curtis Gill MD, Arthur I. Mallinson MSc, Neil S. Londridge MDFRCS. Effects of Dimenhydrinate on Computerized Dynamic Posturography. Journal of otolaryngology, 2000, vol.29(6):337-39.

11. Castagno LA, Richter CM, Cava RA, Costa MH, Castagno Tavares MC, et al. Eletronistagmografia computadorizada na investigao dos distrbios do equilbrio. Acta Awho, 1994, 13(2):42-52.

12. Ganana CF, Souza JAC, Segantin LA, Caovilla HH, Ganana MM. Limites normais dos parmetros de avaliao vectonistagmografia digital neurograff. Acta Awho, 2):105, 2000

13. Flores MR, Franco ES. Vectoeletronistagmografia computadorizada: nistagmo ps-calrico estimulao com ar em indivduos sem queixa. Arq Otorrinolaringol, 2003, 7(4), p.302-308.

14. Campos CAH. Principais quadros clnicos no adulto e no idoso. In: Vertigem tem cura? Lemos editorial, So Paulo, 1998, p.157-70.

15. Albertino S. Migrnea e distrbios vestibulares. In: Vertigem tem cura? Lemos editorial, So Paulo, 1998, p.49-57.

16. Beckham JC, Krug LM, Penzien DB, Johnson CA, MosleyJr. TH et al. The relationship of ovarian steroids, headache activity and menstrual distress: a pilot study with family migraineurs. Headache, 1992, 32(6):292-97.

17. Cass SP, Ankerstjerne JKP, Yetiser S, Furman JM, Balaban C et al. Migraine-related vestibulopathy. Ann. Otol. Rhinol. Laryngol., 1997, 106:182-9.

18. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH.A vertigem e sintomas associados. In: Ganana MM, Vieira RM, Caovilla HH. Princpios de Otoneurologia. Ed. Atheneu, vol.1, So Paulo, 1998, p.3-5.

19. Ganana MM, Caovilla HH, Munhoz MSL, Silva MLG, Ganana FF, Ganana CF et al. Reflexes sobre a farmacoterapia da vertigem: problemas e solues. Parte I- Crenas... RBM-ORL, So Paulo, 1998, vol 5(1):4-12.

20. Ganana MM. Farmacoterapia racional da vertigem. In: Ganana MM. Vertigem tem cura? Ed. Lemos. So Paulo, 1998, p.227-35.

21. Ganana MM Drogas antivertiginosas. In: Ganana MM, Vieira RM, Caovilla HH. Princpios de Otoneurologia. Ed. Atheneu, vol.1, So Paulo, 1991, p.111-16.

22. Ganana MM, Ganana FF. Substncias Antivertiginosas. In: Ganana MM, Munhoz MSL, Caovilla HH, Silva MLG. Estratgias Teraputicas em Otoneurologia, Atheneu, vol.4, So Paulo, 2001, p.67-92.

23. Ganana FF.Tratamento da vertigem e de outras tonturas. Ed.Lemos, So Paulo, 2002

24. Ganana MM, Munhoz MSL, Caovilla HH, Silva MLG, Ganana FF, Perracini MR et al. Conceitos e algoritmos teraputicos. In: Ganana MM, Munhoz MSL, Caovilla HH, Silva MLG. Condutas na vertigem. Ed. Moreira Jnior, So Paulo, 2004, p.55-103.

25. Menon AD, Campos CAH, Sakano E, Weckx LLM, Ganana MM. Frum sobre vertigem. Revista Brasileira de Otorrinolaringologia, 2003, supl 1, 69(4):1-36.

26. Lacour M, Sterkers O. Histamina e Betaistina no tratamento da vertigem. Elucidao dos mecanismos de ao. CNS Drugs, 2001, 15(11):853-870.

27. Lacour M, Tighilet B. Vestibular compensation in the Cat: The role of the histaminergic system. Acta Otolaryngol, 2000, suppl 544:15-18.

28. Kingma H, Bonink M, Meulenbroeks A, Konijnenberg H. Dose-dependent effect of betahistine on the vestbuloocular reflex: a double-blind, placebo controlled study in patients with paroxysmal vertigo. Acta Otolaryngol, 1997, 117(5):641-6.

29. Tighilet B, Trottier S, Mourre C, Chotard C, Lacour M. Betahistine dihydrochloride interaction with the histaminergic system in the cat; neurochemical and molecular mechanisms. Eur J Pharmacol, 2002, 446(1-3):63-73.

30. Mierzwinski J, Kazmierczak H, Pawlak-Osinska K, Piziewicz A. The effect of betahistine on vestibular habituation: comparison of rotatory and sway habituation training. Acta Otolaryngol., 2001, 121(5):610-5.

1. Master (Phonoaudiology).
2. Post Graduation (Phonoaudiology).
3. Post Graduation (Phonoaudiology).

Centro de Especializao em Fonoaudiologia Clnica - CEFAC (Specialization Center on Clinical Phonoaudiology).
Address: Rua Cayowa, 664 - Perdizes - CEP: 05018-000 So Paulo - SP

This article was submitted to SGP - Sistema de Gesto de Publicaes (Publication Management System) from RAIO on January 22, 2006 and was approved on January 27, 2006 22:30:22.



All right reserved. Prohibited the reproduction of papers
without previous authorization of FORL © 1997- 2024